Back
Idd36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e
RulenameAbnormal Deny Rate for Source IP
DescriptionIdentifies abnormal deny rate for specific source IP to destination IP based on the normal average and standard deviation learned during a configured period. This can indicate potential exfiltration, initial access or C2, where attacker tries to exploit the same vulnerability on machines in the organization, but is being blocked by firewall rules.



Configurable Parameters:



- Minimum of stds threshold - the number of stds to use in the threshold calculation. Default is set to 3.

- Learning period time - learning period for threshold calculation in days. Default is set to 5.

- Bin time - learning buckets time in hours. Default is set to 1 hour.

- Minimum threshold - minimum threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.

- Minimum bucket threshold - minimum learning buckets threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.
SeverityMedium
TacticsInitialAccess
Exfiltration
CommandAndControl
Discovery
TechniquesT1190
T1041
T1568.001
T1568.002
T1046
Required data connectorsAzureFirewall
KindScheduled
Query frequency1h
Query period25h
Trigger threshold0
Trigger operatorgt
Source Urihttps://github.com/Azure/Azure-Sentinel/blob/master/Solutions/Azure%20Firewall/Analytic%20Rules/Azure%20Firewall%20-%20Abnormal%20Deny%20Rate%20for%20Source%20IP.yaml
Version1.1.3
Arm templated36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e.json
Deploy To Azure
let LearningPeriod = 1d;
let RunTime = 1h;
let StartLearningPeriod = LearningPeriod + RunTime;
let EndRunTime = RunTime - 1h;
let BinTime = 1h;
let NumOfStdsThreshold = 3;
let MinThreshold = 5.0;
let MinLearningBuckets = 5;
// Restrict unioned tables to the full analysis window to avoid full-table scans
let FullWindowStart = ago(StartLearningPeriod);
let FullWindowEnd = now();
let TrafficLogs = (union isfuzzy=true
(AzureDiagnostics
| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
| where OperationName == "AzureFirewallApplicationRuleLog" or OperationName == "AzureFirewallNetworkRuleLog" 
| parse msg_s with * "from " SourceIp ":" SourcePort:int " to " Fqdn ":" DestinationPort:int ". " * "Action: " Action "." *
| where Action == "Deny"
| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
(AZFWNetworkRule
| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
| where Action == "Deny"
| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
(AZFWFlowTrace
| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
| where Action == "Deny"
| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
(AZFWIdpsSignature
| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
| where Action == "Deny"
| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
(AZFWApplicationRule
| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
| where Action == "Deny"
| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)));
let LearningSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs
| where TimeGenerated between (ago(StartLearningPeriod) .. ago(RunTime))
| summarize count() by SourceIp, bin(TimeGenerated, BinTime), Fqdn
| summarize LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg = avg(count_), LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd = stdev(count_), LearningTimeBuckets = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn
| where LearningTimeBuckets > MinLearningBuckets);
let AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs
| where TimeGenerated between (ago(RunTime) .. ago(EndRunTime))
| summarize AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn);
AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate
| join kind=leftouter (LearningSrcIpDenyRate) on SourceIp, Fqdn
| extend LearningThreshold = max_of(LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg + NumOfStdsThreshold * LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd, MinThreshold)
| where AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount > LearningThreshold
| project SourceIp, Fqdn, AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount, LearningTimeBuckets, LearningThreshold
id: d36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e
entityMappings:
- fieldMappings:
  - columnName: SourceIp
    identifier: Address
  entityType: IP
- fieldMappings:
  - columnName: Fqdn
    identifier: Url
  entityType: URL
severity: Medium
status: Available
customDetails:
  AlertCount: AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount
  Threshold: LearningThreshold
alertDetailsOverride:
  alertDisplayNameFormat: Abnormal Deny Rate for Source IP {{SourceIp}}
  alertDescriptionFormat: |
    The source IP {{SourceIp}} has an abnormal deny rate to destination {{Fqdn}} with {{AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount}} denies, which is above the calculated threshold. This could indicate potential exfiltration, initial access or C2 activities.
requiredDataConnectors:
- dataTypes:
  - AzureDiagnostics
  - AZFWApplicationRule
  - AZFWNetworkRule
  - AZFWFlowTrace
  - AZFWIdpsSignature
  connectorId: AzureFirewall
kind: Scheduled
query: |
  let LearningPeriod = 1d;
  let RunTime = 1h;
  let StartLearningPeriod = LearningPeriod + RunTime;
  let EndRunTime = RunTime - 1h;
  let BinTime = 1h;
  let NumOfStdsThreshold = 3;
  let MinThreshold = 5.0;
  let MinLearningBuckets = 5;
  // Restrict unioned tables to the full analysis window to avoid full-table scans
  let FullWindowStart = ago(StartLearningPeriod);
  let FullWindowEnd = now();
  let TrafficLogs = (union isfuzzy=true
  (AzureDiagnostics
  | where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
  | where OperationName == "AzureFirewallApplicationRuleLog" or OperationName == "AzureFirewallNetworkRuleLog" 
  | parse msg_s with * "from " SourceIp ":" SourcePort:int " to " Fqdn ":" DestinationPort:int ". " * "Action: " Action "." *
  | where Action == "Deny"
  | where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
  (AZFWNetworkRule
  | where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
  | extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
  | where Action == "Deny"
  | where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
  (AZFWFlowTrace
  | where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
  | extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
  | where Action == "Deny"
  | where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
  (AZFWIdpsSignature
  | where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
  | extend Fqdn = DestinationIp
  | where Action == "Deny"
  | where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),
  (AZFWApplicationRule
  | where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)
  | where Action == "Deny"
  | where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)));
  let LearningSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs
  | where TimeGenerated between (ago(StartLearningPeriod) .. ago(RunTime))
  | summarize count() by SourceIp, bin(TimeGenerated, BinTime), Fqdn
  | summarize LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg = avg(count_), LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd = stdev(count_), LearningTimeBuckets = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn
  | where LearningTimeBuckets > MinLearningBuckets);
  let AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs
  | where TimeGenerated between (ago(RunTime) .. ago(EndRunTime))
  | summarize AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn);
  AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate
  | join kind=leftouter (LearningSrcIpDenyRate) on SourceIp, Fqdn
  | extend LearningThreshold = max_of(LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg + NumOfStdsThreshold * LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd, MinThreshold)
  | where AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount > LearningThreshold
  | project SourceIp, Fqdn, AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount, LearningTimeBuckets, LearningThreshold
name: Abnormal Deny Rate for Source IP
queryPeriod: 25h
description: |
  'Identifies abnormal deny rate for specific source IP to destination IP based on the normal average and standard deviation learned during a configured period. This can indicate potential exfiltration, initial access or C2, where attacker tries to exploit the same vulnerability on machines in the organization, but is being blocked by firewall rules.

  Configurable Parameters:

  - Minimum of stds threshold - the number of stds to use in the threshold calculation. Default is set to 3.
  - Learning period time - learning period for threshold calculation in days. Default is set to 5.
  - Bin time - learning buckets time in hours. Default is set to 1 hour.
  - Minimum threshold - minimum threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.
  - Minimum bucket threshold - minimum learning buckets threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.'
tactics:
- InitialAccess
- Exfiltration
- CommandAndControl
- Discovery
triggerOperator: gt
triggerThreshold: 0
relevantTechniques:
- T1190
- T1041
- T1568.001
- T1568.002
- T1046
version: 1.1.3
OriginalUri: https://github.com/Azure/Azure-Sentinel/blob/master/Solutions/Azure%20Firewall/Analytic%20Rules/Azure%20Firewall%20-%20Abnormal%20Deny%20Rate%20for%20Source%20IP.yaml
queryFrequency: 1h
{
  "$schema": "https://schema.management.azure.com/schemas/2019-04-01/deploymentTemplate.json#",
  "contentVersion": "1.0.0.0",
  "parameters": {
    "workspace": {
      "type": "String"
    }
  },
  "resources": [
    {
      "apiVersion": "2024-01-01-preview",
      "id": "[concat(resourceId('Microsoft.OperationalInsights/workspaces/providers', parameters('workspace'), 'Microsoft.SecurityInsights'),'/alertRules/d36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e')]",
      "kind": "Scheduled",
      "name": "[concat(parameters('workspace'),'/Microsoft.SecurityInsights/d36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e')]",
      "properties": {
        "alertDetailsOverride": {
          "alertDescriptionFormat": "The source IP {{SourceIp}} has an abnormal deny rate to destination {{Fqdn}} with {{AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount}} denies, which is above the calculated threshold. This could indicate potential exfiltration, initial access or C2 activities.\n",
          "alertDisplayNameFormat": "Abnormal Deny Rate for Source IP {{SourceIp}}"
        },
        "alertRuleTemplateName": "d36bb1e3-5abc-4037-ad9a-24ba3469819e",
        "customDetails": {
          "AlertCount": "AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount",
          "Threshold": "LearningThreshold"
        },
        "description": "'Identifies abnormal deny rate for specific source IP to destination IP based on the normal average and standard deviation learned during a configured period. This can indicate potential exfiltration, initial access or C2, where attacker tries to exploit the same vulnerability on machines in the organization, but is being blocked by firewall rules.\n\nConfigurable Parameters:\n\n- Minimum of stds threshold - the number of stds to use in the threshold calculation. Default is set to 3.\n- Learning period time - learning period for threshold calculation in days. Default is set to 5.\n- Bin time - learning buckets time in hours. Default is set to 1 hour.\n- Minimum threshold - minimum threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.\n- Minimum bucket threshold - minimum learning buckets threshold for alert. Default is set to 5.'\n",
        "displayName": "Abnormal Deny Rate for Source IP",
        "enabled": true,
        "entityMappings": [
          {
            "entityType": "IP",
            "fieldMappings": [
              {
                "columnName": "SourceIp",
                "identifier": "Address"
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "entityType": "URL",
            "fieldMappings": [
              {
                "columnName": "Fqdn",
                "identifier": "Url"
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "OriginalUri": "https://github.com/Azure/Azure-Sentinel/blob/master/Solutions/Azure%20Firewall/Analytic%20Rules/Azure%20Firewall%20-%20Abnormal%20Deny%20Rate%20for%20Source%20IP.yaml",
        "query": "let LearningPeriod = 1d;\nlet RunTime = 1h;\nlet StartLearningPeriod = LearningPeriod + RunTime;\nlet EndRunTime = RunTime - 1h;\nlet BinTime = 1h;\nlet NumOfStdsThreshold = 3;\nlet MinThreshold = 5.0;\nlet MinLearningBuckets = 5;\n// Restrict unioned tables to the full analysis window to avoid full-table scans\nlet FullWindowStart = ago(StartLearningPeriod);\nlet FullWindowEnd = now();\nlet TrafficLogs = (union isfuzzy=true\n(AzureDiagnostics\n| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)\n| where OperationName == \"AzureFirewallApplicationRuleLog\" or OperationName == \"AzureFirewallNetworkRuleLog\" \n| parse msg_s with * \"from \" SourceIp \":\" SourcePort:int \" to \" Fqdn \":\" DestinationPort:int \". \" * \"Action: \" Action \".\" *\n| where Action == \"Deny\"\n| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),\n(AZFWNetworkRule\n| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)\n| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp\n| where Action == \"Deny\"\n| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),\n(AZFWFlowTrace\n| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)\n| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp\n| where Action == \"Deny\"\n| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),\n(AZFWIdpsSignature\n| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)\n| extend Fqdn = DestinationIp\n| where Action == \"Deny\"\n| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)),\n(AZFWApplicationRule\n| where TimeGenerated between (FullWindowStart .. FullWindowEnd)\n| where Action == \"Deny\"\n| where isnotempty(Fqdn) and isnotempty(SourceIp)));\nlet LearningSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs\n| where TimeGenerated between (ago(StartLearningPeriod) .. ago(RunTime))\n| summarize count() by SourceIp, bin(TimeGenerated, BinTime), Fqdn\n| summarize LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg = avg(count_), LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd = stdev(count_), LearningTimeBuckets = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn\n| where LearningTimeBuckets > MinLearningBuckets);\nlet AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate = (TrafficLogs\n| where TimeGenerated between (ago(RunTime) .. ago(EndRunTime))\n| summarize AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount = count() by SourceIp, Fqdn);\nAlertTimeSrcIpDenyRate\n| join kind=leftouter (LearningSrcIpDenyRate) on SourceIp, Fqdn\n| extend LearningThreshold = max_of(LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateAvg + NumOfStdsThreshold * LearningTimeSrcIpDenyRateStd, MinThreshold)\n| where AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount > LearningThreshold\n| project SourceIp, Fqdn, AlertTimeSrcIpDenyRateCount, LearningTimeBuckets, LearningThreshold\n",
        "queryFrequency": "PT1H",
        "queryPeriod": "PT25H",
        "severity": "Medium",
        "status": "Available",
        "subTechniques": [
          "T1568.001",
          "T1568.002"
        ],
        "suppressionDuration": "PT1H",
        "suppressionEnabled": false,
        "tactics": [
          "CommandAndControl",
          "Discovery",
          "Exfiltration",
          "InitialAccess"
        ],
        "techniques": [
          "T1041",
          "T1046",
          "T1190",
          "T1568"
        ],
        "templateVersion": "1.1.3",
        "triggerOperator": "GreaterThan",
        "triggerThreshold": 0
      },
      "type": "Microsoft.OperationalInsights/workspaces/providers/alertRules"
    }
  ]
}